Legal Reasoning as a Field of Knowledge Production: Luhmann, Bourdieu and Law’s Autonomy
Access status:
Open Access
Type
Conference paperAuthor/s
van Krieken, RobertAbstract
This paper pursues an improved theoretical understanding of the particular position of legal rationality in relation to other, competing, modes of thinking about human behaviour and social institutions. Against the background of the existing literature on the role of scientific ...
See moreThis paper pursues an improved theoretical understanding of the particular position of legal rationality in relation to other, competing, modes of thinking about human behaviour and social institutions. Against the background of the existing literature on the role of scientific expert evidence in legal proceedings, the paper critically reconstructs Luhmann’s arguments concerning the combined normative or operational “closure” and “cognitive openness” of the legal system, and relates these arguments to Bourdieu’s work on the internal functioning of the juridical “field”. It then puts those conceptual insights “to work” with reference to a number of empirical examples of the role of extra-legal forms of knowledge - in particular, history and anthropology - within the Australian High Court and Federal Court jurisprudence regarding native title.
See less
See moreThis paper pursues an improved theoretical understanding of the particular position of legal rationality in relation to other, competing, modes of thinking about human behaviour and social institutions. Against the background of the existing literature on the role of scientific expert evidence in legal proceedings, the paper critically reconstructs Luhmann’s arguments concerning the combined normative or operational “closure” and “cognitive openness” of the legal system, and relates these arguments to Bourdieu’s work on the internal functioning of the juridical “field”. It then puts those conceptual insights “to work” with reference to a number of empirical examples of the role of extra-legal forms of knowledge - in particular, history and anthropology - within the Australian High Court and Federal Court jurisprudence regarding native title.
See less
Date
2004-05-01Citation
‘Legal Reasoning as a field of knowledge production’, Law, Power & Injustice: Confronting the Legacies of Sociolegal Research, Law & Society Association Conference, Chicago 27-29 May 2004.Share