Beliefs and beyond: what can we learn from qualitative studies of lay people’s understandings of cancer risk?

Abstract

Background: Clinicians and public health professionals are centrally concerned with mediating risk. However people often resist the risk-related information that is communicated to them by experts, or have their own models of risk that conflict with expert views. Quantitative studies have clearly demonstrated the importance of health beliefs and various cognitive and emotional processes in shaping risk perception. More recently, a growing body of qualitative research has emerged, exploring lay conceptualisations, experiences and constructions of cancer risk. To date, this literature has not been synthesised. Objective: We report the findings of a synthesis of qualitative literature regarding the ways in which lay people construct and experience cancer risk. Design: We identified 87 articles and used the method of “thematic synthesis” to identify and interpret key concepts from existing studies. Results: Eight analytic categories were developed: 1) perceptions of risk factors; 2) process of risk perception; 3) seeking control and taking responsibility (motivational factors); 4) experiencing cancer directly; 5) constructing risk temporally; 6) embodying risk; 7) identifying with risk; and 8) constructing risk in a social context. Conclusions: Qualitative enquiry can provide us with a rich and nuanced picture of the ways in which people understand, experience and construct risk and how being ‘at risk’ is managed, and can assist us in our communication with both individual patients and populations.